« Funeral Home Directors Are Our Friends | Main | Footnote Frenzy »

Immigration Paradise!

The last couple of months have been a virtual paradise for those of us who are into immigration records. First came a massive update to Ancestry.com's Immigration Collection with the addition of millions of records from 1820 to 1960.

And then came the addition of Hamburg Emigration and other German records, announced by Ancestry.com yesterday. I amused myself by going here and searching for "Hasselhoff" records.

And now comes the announcement of emigration records from the British National Archives (just 1890-1899 for now, but eventually going to 1960) from Find My Past.

I took the opportunity to play with this site this morning, and find it very promising. It offers not only the expected British records, but many records for Irish and even mainland Europeans who traveled to other locations via the U.K. I also like the prospect it provides of being able to tie together families that emigrated to different countries. For instance, I belong to a branch of Nelligans who came to the U.S., but have always heard of a branch that went to Australia, so I intend to experiment with Find My Past to see if I might be able to pick up a trail.

The search functionality of the site is fine, and when you get cursory results, you can opt for either a transcript or a digital image (see below for an example of a transcript that includes passenger name, place of departure, destination port, and a few other details, such as others traveling with that passenger). I also snagged a digital image and found it to be very legible and fairly easy to maneuver around.

View image

I do have a couple of minor gripes, though. Unfortunately, I find that the site doesn't play well with Firefox when it comes to viewing transcripts and images (not without some effort anyway), so it's probably best to use Explorer. That's not a huge deal, but what I really don't care for is the credits/time approach to searching. Mind you, Find My Past is not the only site to use this approach, but it still irritates me.

Basically, you have a series of options for buying packets of credits -- and the more you buy, the lower the price-per-credit goes. You then use these credits to view either transcripts (10 credits) or digital images (25 credits). This pricing approach drives me nuts because it forces the user to be overly strategic in their searching. Unless you want to over-spend, you have to carefully consider each and every view, and that's a challenging way to research. I like to get in there and really "work" a database, so I much prefer to pay one flat annual fee (I'd even be willing to pay a premium for this) and be done with it. When I search, I want to focus on the search and not the ticking meter.

Also, it's important to be aware that each packet comes with an expiration date (perhaps a month or a year). So if you purchase a packet, do some searching, and still have some leftover credits, you had better make a mental note or you could lose those credits down the road a bit -- if, like many, you periodically dive in for some research, leave it for a bit, and then dive in again.

Again, I prefer subscription options that don't require me to monitor them so closely. That may be a personal problem because I have so many online subscriptions that it's a hassle to keep these kinds of details straight. And I want to emphasize that Find My Past is far from the only site that uses this approach. In general, it's pretty popular with European genealogical websites.

So please don't let my venting on this particular issue scare you off from Find My Past. I am a customer and intend to remain one, and I'm excited at the prospect of what I might be able to find. I'm just hoping that they'll consider offering a flat-fee pricing option at some point!

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.rootstelevision.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/216

Comments (2)

rsnoops:

Obviously, I can't speak for Find My Past, but as an operator of an other site with the pay-as-you-use model I can offer a simple answer to your question about why this model is used - at least in my case. Might hold true for Find My Past, though, too.

If Gene Doe has unmetered access to the records, what would restrain him from looking up a record (or two, maybe three, or wait, godforbid, four) for a friend, uncle, society fellow, etc.? Or, sparing all this bother and going to the next level, why wouldn't he simple pass his username/password so that others could dig for their pleasure?

Setting an allowance really stops misuse. On the other side, the allowance should be gracious enough so that it would not hinder fair researchers.

Hello Megan,

Very pleased that you're finding the Ancestorsonboard.com passenger lists of such interest. I just wanted to respond on a couple of points about pay-per-view. The other view is that it is much fairer to be able to just pay for what you need, and to be have a low-cost way of accessing records without having to sign up to a major financial commitment for a year or so (or longer if you don't remember to cancel your direct debit).

This low-cost entry point is a requirement for companies operating services in association with The National Archives here in the UK. It means that customers can dip their toes in from around $10 with no ongoing commitment. This is a public service/accessibility issue, and is considered fairer than locking you in to a service that means paying for access to records you may not need.

The minimum expiry time on the findmypast.com is three months, rather than one month, for the $10 package, and most packages are valid for one year. We send emails to remind you when units are about to expire and you have an opportunity to extend the life of units.

Finally, you may be pleased to hear that we will shortly be introducing unlimited access subscription packages for the passenger list records alongside the pay-per-view options, so each researcher can decide which payment method meets their needs. It's about customer choice.

We'll also take a look at the Firefox issue!

Kind regards,

Elaine Collins
Commercial Director, Findmypast.com Ancestorsonboard.com

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on January 10, 2007 3:20 PM.

The previous post in this blog was Funeral Home Directors Are Our Friends.

The next post in this blog is Footnote Frenzy.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Powered by
Movable Type 3.31