Wow, I know we've become borderline paranoid about privacy in recent years, but even I was startled the other day when I had to provide a copy of my drivers license for -- get this -- a marriage record from 1894 and a death record from 1908. Mind you, there was no requirement to be related to the individuals in the records, so this wasn't a matter of proving a blood tie. This is simply routine procedure at the repository involved.
Is our fear of fraud and/or terrorism so great that we really need to track exactly who's ordering copies of century-old marriage records or 99-year-old death records? Is this truly protecting anyone from anything?
Even if these documents could somehow be used to, say, commit a crime (sorry, but my feeble brain can't quite figure out how), I maintain that criminals are too lazy to work this hard. Aren't criminals mostly folks who want a lot for a little? Do we really think they would take the time to research someone's grandparents in order to try to steal their identity? Wouldn't snagging their wallet, running their credit card twice when they shop, or buying card numbers from fellow criminals be a lot easier?
What do you think? Am I over-reacting or do I have reason to be perplexed?
Comments (4)
I think there's way too much paranoia out there. I'm going back in my cave.
Randy
Posted by Randolph Clark | March 25, 2007 7:40 PM
Posted on March 25, 2007 19:40
I'm glad to see your comments. I agree with you completely. My assessment is that those persons who are grossly over preoccupied w/ creating rules, or implementing new policy that it almost doesn't matter whether its really effective, or if the implementation is actually more time consuming and costly then what is actually required to remedy the problem. I'm nearly sick to death (literally) of having to give my genealogical history just to accomplish the most simple transaction. And the irony is that others are so sheepish about it that any objection is obstracized or demeaned.
Each time I encounter these invasions of privacy, my thinking is that any entity or agency will conduct numerous meetings with staff or other pertinent personnel before a decision is made. So, where are all the people who ask questions or pose the what-ifs during these meetings when they make all of these innovative and genius decisions on the behalf of the American public. I personally am striving for the confidence to get people involved in getting those who they elect to actually work for the benefit of the constituents and to defend their rights, especially when millions of homeland security dollars are repeatedly reported in the news as having been wasted, mishandled or misplaced.
Posted by isis | March 26, 2007 3:00 PM
Posted on March 26, 2007 15:00
Megan, you have it exactly correct. One additional thing I am concerned about, is the potential that my own sensative information will be compromised, in their attempts to protect the privacy of the dead. I am in the process of obtaining an AZ death certificate of a recently deceased relative. They require a copy of ones birth (or marriage) certificate, to prove ones relationship to the deceased. For handy payment one can enter their credit card informaion, since they do not accept personal checks. Should this fall into the wrong hands there is a great deal of information that would be very handy for a crook to have. Information that would hurt me, NOT, recently passed, Great Aunt Tilly.
On a positive note, some of Arizona's vital document fees have actually been reduced. In one case from $28, down to $10, as of the the first of 2007.
Posted by Judy | March 30, 2007 6:04 PM
Posted on March 30, 2007 18:04
I agree. My grandmother was in two Texas State Hospitals from 1926 until her death in 1951. I am not allowed to have her records because of the sake of identity theft. I believe if I am able to prove that I am her direct granddaughter and not an illegal alien, I should be able to obtain all her records in which might lead me to be able to find the birth and burial place of my grandfather.
I think there should be some way in which legal citizens can acquire their direct ancestors records.
Patricia
Posted by Patricia | April 4, 2007 4:03 PM
Posted on April 4, 2007 16:03